Singaporeans and Foreigners — Labour Market

Singapore is a thriving island nation with a name for itself globally thanks to its high-quality education system, robust economy, and multiculturalism. The country is known for its vibrant mix of cultures, evident in its food, architecture, and festivals. With its efficient public transportation system, low crime rate, and high standard of living, Singapore is a popular destination for tourists and expatriates alike.

However, in recent years, there has been growing concern among locals about the competition from foreigners in the job market. Singaporeans have expressed frustration with the perception that foreigners are taking away good jobs from them, leading to resentment and a sense of injustice. This has led to calls for more protectionist policies to be put in place to safeguard the interests of Singaporeans.

Despite these challenges, Singapore remains a dynamic and prosperous nation that continues attracting investors and business people worldwide. The government has put in place various measures to address locals' concerns, such as improving the quality of education and offering more training opportunities. With its strong economy, diverse population, and excellent infrastructure, Singapore is poised to continue its success story in the years to come.

Immigration Policies

One of the primary factors contributing to the perception among Singaporeans that they are fighting foreigners for good jobs is the country's immigration policies. Singapore has a relatively open immigration policy, which has led to an influx of foreign talent. According to a 2019 report by the Ministry of Manpower, the number of Employment Pass holders in Singapore has increased steadily over the years, from 83,000 in 2010 to 195,000 in 2019. This increase has led many Singaporeans to believe that foreigners are taking away their job opportunities.

Moreover, many Singaporeans feel that the government's immigration policies are too lax, leading to an influx of foreign talent that is taking away their job opportunities. For instance, according to a survey conducted by the Institute of Policy Studies in 2018, 60% of Singaporeans believe that there are too many foreigners. Some also feel that the government prioritises foreign workers over locals, who are often willing to work for lower salaries. This perception is not unfounded, as data from the Ministry of Manpower shows that in 2019, the median monthly wage of Employment Pass holders was SGD 6,000, while the median monthly salary of local professionals was SGD 5,500.

To address these concerns, the government has recently implemented several measures. For example, in 2020, the Ministry of Manpower announced raising the minimum qualifying salary for Employment Pass holders from SGD 3,600 to SGD 4,500. This was done to ensure that Singaporean professionals have a fair chance of securing good jobs. The government has also tightened the criteria for S Passes, which are work permits for mid-level skilled workers, and increased the foreign worker levy for companies that employ more than 25% of foreign workers.

In addition to immigration policies, cultural differences have also been identified as contributing to the perception that Singaporeans are fighting foreigners for good jobs. According to a survey by the Ministry of Manpower, 37% of Singaporeans felt that foreigners were better at communicating in English than they were, while 30% felt that foreigners were more assertive or outspoken. These perceptions can create tension and lead to resentment.

Many Singapore companies have implemented cultural sensitivity training programmes to address this issue. For example, DBS Bank has a diversity and inclusion programme that includes employee cultural awareness training. The training covers cultural differences, communication styles, and business etiquette. Such programmes can create a more harmonious work environment where everyone feels valued and respected. In addition, companies need to provide opportunities for employees to interact with people from different backgrounds, as this can help to promote understanding and break down cultural barriers.

Overall, the issue of Singaporeans fighting foreigners for good jobs is complex and can only be fully understood considering the various factors at play. While the government has taken steps to address the concerns of Singaporeans, it is essential for individuals to also take action by developing their skills and qualifications to remain competitive in the job market.

Cultural Differences

Cultural differences have contributed to the perception that Singaporeans are fighting foreigners for good jobs. Singapore is a highly diverse country, with people from various ethnic and cultural backgrounds living and working together. However, cultural differences can sometimes lead to misunderstandings and miscommunications in the workplace. In a survey conducted by the Ministry of Manpower, it was found that 37% of Singaporeans felt that foreigners were better at communicating in English than they were. In addition, 30% of Singaporeans felt that foreigners were more assertive or outspoken than they were. Such perceptions can create tension and lead to resentment.

Many Singapore companies have implemented cultural sensitivity training programmes to address this issue. These programmes promote understanding and mutual respect between employees from different cultural backgrounds. For example, DBS Bank has a diversity and inclusion programme that includes employee cultural awareness training. The training covers cultural differences, communication styles, and business etiquette. Such programmes can create a more harmonious work environment where everyone feels valued and respected. In addition, companies need to provide opportunities for employees to interact with people from different backgrounds, as this can help to promote understanding and break down cultural barriers.

Overall, while cultural differences can create challenges in the workplace, it is essential to recognise that diversity is a strength and can bring many benefits to organisations. By promoting understanding and respect between employees from different cultural backgrounds, companies in Singapore can create a more inclusive and productive work environment that benefits everyone.

Economic Factors

Economic factors play a significant role in the issue of Singaporeans fighting foreigners for good jobs. Singapore's highly competitive economy relies heavily on innovation, technology, and human capital. According to a report by the World Economic Forum, Singapore ranks second in the world for competitiveness, with solid scores in infrastructure, health, and education. This competitive environment attracts foreign talent with skills and expertise in high demand, particularly in finance, IT, and healthcare.

Singapore's foreigners often possess high qualifications and experience, making them more competitive in the job market. For example, a survey by the Ministry of Manpower found that in 2019, 55% of Employment Pass holders in Singapore held a master's degree or higher, compared to just 15% of local workers. This disparity in qualifications can make it difficult for Singaporeans to compete for high-paying jobs.

However, it is essential to note that the competition for good jobs is more comprehensive than for foreigners alone. Singaporeans also face competition from other Singaporeans, as well as from people in other countries who are willing to work remotely. For example, the COVID-19 pandemic has increased remote work opportunities, allowing people from around the world to work for Singaporean companies without having to relocate. This has created a more globalised job market, making it even more competitive for Singaporeans to secure good jobs.

In conclusion, economic factors contribute significantly to the issue of Singaporeans fighting foreigners for good jobs. The highly competitive nature of the Singaporean economy attracts foreign talent with skills and expertise that are in high demand. To remain competitive, Singaporeans must continue to develop their skills and qualifications and adapt to the changing job market.

Conclusion

The issue of Singaporeans fighting foreigners for good jobs is complex and can only be fully understood by considering the various factors at play. Using the MECE framework, we have identified three main categories contributing to this issue: immigration policies, cultural differences, and economic factors.

While there is no easy solution to this problem, it is clear that the government and private sector are taking steps to address the concerns of Singaporeans.

Citations

at